1

I have seen this several times, for example, this post. At the moment of asking this there are only 6 visible comments, but the total number says it's 7. Why is that?

  • I see 7 - i.stack.imgur.com/WjVbV.png – user0 Feb 18 '19 at 3:18
  • perhaps cache? I did refresh the page before asking, but at the time it was still 6 – Ooker Feb 18 '19 at 3:31
  • most likely it's due to filter check. comment count will rise the moment comment is posted, but the comment itself isn't visible to public unless is checked against some filter (for rudeness, harassment, spam, caps, could be anything...) and when ok, it gets public. also there could ba a front to ease the load – user0 Feb 18 '19 at 3:40
  • hmm, presumably that this filter is automatic (no human can handle the filter comment), then shouldn't the effect come immediately? – Ooker Feb 18 '19 at 3:42
  • yeah, for 1 comment - sure. for 10000+ comments posted in exact second - not so sure – user0 Feb 18 '19 at 3:45
1

It's probably because of removed comment(s). Among possible reasons are: removal by Reddit's site-wide automated spam filters, or if a user is shadowbanned in Reddit.

A shadowban is the tool we currently use to ban people when they are caught breaking a rule. It causes their submitted content and user profile page to be visible only to themselves while logged in. Moderators can see their comments within their subreddit (since they can see "removed" comments in the subreddit they moderate), but no other users can see their content, and nobody else can see their userpage.

Moderators of a subreddit can also remove comments within the subreddit they moderate. They can also automate removal of comments, including all comments by a specific user through AutoModerator.

From Reddit's FAQ page:

There are missing comments in a thread

If you find a thread that says there are more comments than you can see in the thread, the "missing" comments were probably removed - by the moderators of that subreddit, by the reddit spam filter, or by the subreddit's local AutoModerator. A comment which is removed in this way actually stays in the thread; it is merely hidden so that readers can't see it. So, reddit counts a removed comment in the total comments for a thread, but doesn't display it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.