0

How should I comment on someone else's tweet to make my comment visible to the original tweeter and other users looking at the original tweet replies and my own followers?

I've noticed that if I "retweet with comment" someone's tweet then my followers will see it, but it doesn't show up in the original tweet as a reply, and I don't think it shows up as a retweet.

If I reply to a tweet then it is only shown on the timeline of users that follow both me and the original tweeter.

If I link to the tweet then it is taken out of the original twitter thread.

1

You can retweet your own posts and replies. If you want to both reply to a thread so that your reply stays within the thread and make sure that your reply shows up on your followers' timelines, you can retweet your own reply after you've posted it so that it shows up.

So step 1: Write your reply. Step 2: Retweet your own reply. Step 3: Have it show up in your followers' timelines (although it will show up as "X retweeted...."). (Step 4: ??? Step 5: Profit.)

As an aside, your regular replies will show up sometimes naturally in their timelines. The algorithm works in mysterious ways, but I will see replies sometimes from people I follow when sorting my Twitter feed by "latest" instead of "top Tweets".

New contributor
Mithrandir is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
0

There is no way to reply to a tweet and at the same time have that reply-tweet appear as public tweet. The most common work-around is as follows:

  1. Click the 🗘 retweet button and select Retweet with comment (on mobile) or use the Add a comment... field (on desktop).
  2. Begin your tweet with .@username, after it type in your reply. Make sure to put a dot . before the @username otherwise your tweet will be processed as a reply:

enter image description here

  1. The result of this method will be a public tweet where the @username you are replying to is @mentioned right at the top, followed by your reply, while the tweet you are replying to is quoted at the bottom:

enter image description here

  1. Last, copy the URL of the reply tweet and paste it in a new public tweet with a bit of context. That would be your public tweet (with the reply) available to all your followers.
  • Thank you. Unfortunately that doesn't show up as a RT for the tweet, nor appear threaded under the original tweet. – conradj Jul 30 at 8:02
  • In that case, what you can do is first reply to the tweet you wish to reply to and then copy the URL of the reply tweet and paste it in a new public tweet with a bit of context – Elad Ratson Jul 30 at 9:25
  • I guess I could retweet my answer instead? What's the difference? Anyway, I think this is the best solution if you want to add that to your answer? – conradj Jul 31 at 12:30
  • edited the answer... – Elad Ratson Jul 31 at 20:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.